PROCEEDINGS OF THE ST. JOHN THE BAPTIST PARISH SCHOOL BOARD
ST. JOHN PARISH SCHOOL BOARD SPECIAL MEETING
August 6, 2020 – 6:30 p.m.
Via Zoom Teleconference & Streamed Live on St. John the Baptist Parish Public Schools Facebook Page
Due to the public health emergency caused by the Covid-19 virus and in the interest of the health and safety of the public and the School Board, the St. John the Baptist Parish School Board will meet in special session via teleconference utilizing Zoom Video Conferencing. (See attached Certification of Inability to Operate Due to the Lack of a Quorum.) The meeting will be streamed live on St. John the Baptist Parish Public Schools Facebook Page so that members of the public may view the meeting in real time. All public comments regarding agenda items should be sent to: Public-Board-Comments@stjohn.k12.la.us between 6:00 and 6:30 p.m. on Thursday, August 6, 2020. Public comments must include all three (3) of the following: 1. First and Last Name; 2. Agenda Item Number you are commenting on; 3. Your comment. All public comments will be read aloud before each agenda item is discussed.
The St. John the Baptist Parish School Board will meet on Thursday, August 6, 2020 at 6:30 p.m. via teleconference (Zoom). The meeting will be open to receive Public Comment at 6:00 p.m. The meeting will be in recess until 6:30 p.m. to allow for Public Comment to be received and will reconvene in regular session at 6:30 p.m.
The agenda is attached for the meeting.
The President then read the agenda aloud and recessed the meeting for 30 minutes to allow for public comment.
ITEM 1. CALL TO ORDER, INVOCATION, PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
The Chair reconvened the meeting in Regular Session at 6:30 p.m. He called for a moment of silent meditation, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance, led by Dr. Keller.
ITEM 2. ROLL CALL OF MEMBERS: The Chair called for Public Comment.
PRESENT: Holden, Burl, Keller, DeFrancesch, Jones, Johnson, Schum, Mitchell, Sanders
ABSENT: Wallace, Triche
There were 9 members present and 2 members absent.
ITEM 3. Public Comment. Ms. Iman Montgomery - Introduction to Policy EBBI – COVID-19 Public Health Emergency.
Ms. Montgomery presented the Policy EBBI-COVID-19 Public Health Emergency for introduction.
***************************************
EBBI - COVID-19 PUBLIC HEALTH EMERGENCY
In light of the COVID-19 pandemic and the resulting public health emergency for the
2020-2021 school year, the Superintendent is authorized to develop, implement, and maintain administrative regulations and procedures necessary to protect employees, students, and others from the conditions giving rise to the declared emergency.
In the development and implementation of necessary administrative regulations and procedures for safely reopening schools and for maintaining the safety of employees, students, and others when schools are open during a health emergency, the Superintendent and staff shall rely upon the practices, guidelines, and suggestions of the Louisiana Department of Education in coordination with the Louisiana Department of Health. The Superintendent is authorized to develop and revise plans for reopening schools or maintaining the safety of employees, students, and others and to make required submissions to governmental authorities with regard thereto.
In the event that the Superintendent develops or implements administrative rules, regulations, or procedures, or alters the school reopening plan in any substantive fashion, he/she shall advise the Board of such developments no later than the next regular meeting of the Board.
The St. John the Baptist Parish School Board adopts and incorporates as if set forth fully herein the required provisions of Chapter 4 of Bulletin 741, Louisiana Handbook for School Administrators, for the 2020-2021 school year and shall abide by the required health and safety standards included therein or in any amendments thereto.1
In no event shall the Board’s reopening plan for the 2020-2021 school year be interpreted to include any standard less than that required by Chapter 4 of Bulletin 741, including the following standards:
A. Group Sizes
1. The maximum group sizes that may convene indoors in a single room, irrespective of room size, or outdoors at any given time are as follows:
a. Phase One – 10 individuals;
b. Phase Two – 25 individuals; and
c. Phase Three – 50 individuals.
These maximum numbers shall include students, teachers, and others who are present.
2. Group Composition
a. Younger students, who are not required to wear face coverings or not capable of maintaining a physical distance from other students or adults, will be assigned to static groups. This includes, at a minimum, students in grades 2 or lower. The static group composition will be maintained for as long as possible over the course of the 2020-2021 school year.
i. Physical Distance means the act of an individual maintaining a space of 6 feet or more from another individual.
ii. Static Group means a group whose composition of students and adults does not change.
b. The composition of a group may change if students are able to maintain a physical distance of at least six (6) feet from other students and adults in a classroom or indoor setting, to the greatest extent possible.
c. Students with disabilities will continue to receive special education and related services in the least restrictive environment. The reopening plan will factor in any additional service providers who may need to enter the classroom, students who may need to receive services outside the classroom (e.g., resource, APE), and/or students who may need to receive services through alternate instructional methods.
B. Physical Standards for the Use of School Facilities
1. If a group convenes indoors, it must convene in a room enclosed by a wall or partition. This includes large rooms, such as gymnasiums or auditoriums, which may include more than one group at a time if each group is separated by a wall or partition.
2. If a group convenes outdoors, a wall or partition is not required but each group must remain separated from any other group(s). School principals are given the authority to create and implement recess schedules so that groups remain separated and do not exceed maximum group sizes.
3. To the greatest extent possible, each school shall avoid crowding at entry and exit points of each building, classroom, and restroom and shall, to the extent possible, maintain group sizes and physical distance requirements.
4. If a room is used by more than one group in a single day, high-touch surfaces contained in that room must be cleaned before and after use by each group.
a. High-Touch Surfaces means surfaces that are touched frequently, such as door handles, bathroom fixtures, drinking fountains, railings, desks, and other surfaces in school facilities or on school buses.
C. Monitoring Students and Adults for Symptoms of COVID-19
1. Upon arriving at the school or workplace facility, each employee, student, and other person must be assessed for symptoms of COVID-19. As defined by the CDC, such symptoms would include cough, trouble breathing, and/or temperature of 100.4 degrees or higher. Procedures for assessment would include physical observation and taking of temperature of each employee, student, or other upon his/her arrival on campus. Each principal/workplace supervisor shall determine the most efficient way to accomplish such assessments at his/her school or work site.
2. Each principal/workplace supervisor shall establish an area used to isolate anyone exhibiting symptoms of COVID-19. Any employee or visitor exhibiting such symptoms will not be allowed to remain on the campus/worksite and shall be asked to immediately depart. Any student exhibiting symptoms of COVID-19 shall be directed to the Isolation Area for observation until picked up by a parent/custodian or until the student is authorized to drive or walk home. The Isolation Area must be cleaned after it is occupied by any individual exhibiting symptoms of COVID-19.
D. Environmental Cleaning and Personal Hygiene
1. High-touch surfaces and bathrooms must be cleaned multiple times per day. School bus seats, seat backs, handrails, and other high contact surfaces on school buses shall be cleaned after each use of those buses, i.e., after morning routes, afternoon routes, and special routes.
2. Employees, students, and school or workplace visitors should wash or sanitize their hands upon arrival at the school or workplace, at least every two (2) hours thereafter, before and after eating, and before exiting the school facility. In addition, students should wash or sanitize their hands before and after usage of indoor or outdoor playground equipment.
E. Face Coverings
1. While inside any school facility or on school buses, all students in grades
3 through 12 and all employees and visitors are required to wear face coverings to the greatest extent possible and practicable.
a. Face Covering means a piece of material used to cover both the nose and mouth for the purpose of forming a barrier to droplets or airborne particles that are coughed, sneezed, or exhaled when talking. Face coverings are meant to protect both the wearer of the face covering and surrounding individuals.
b. The face covering is considered part of the school uniform/dress code for both students and employees (see Board policy/student handbook/employee handbook). The failure/refusal of employees and students to wear such face coverings shall result in their immediate separation from others and, for students, notification to the parent/custodian. Thereafter, the incident shall be treated like all other violations of Board policy and/or the student/employee dress/grooming code.
c. Face coverings shall be solid in color and shall contain no pictures, writings, or messages of any kind. Notwithstanding this requirement, face coverings that contain references to the school system (i.e., name or insignia) or individual schools within the system (i.e., name or mascot), which are provided to students by the school system or by individual schools within the system, may be worn.
2. While inside school facilities or on school buses, students in grades pre-Kindergarten through 2 may wear face coverings but are not required to do so.
3. While inside school facilities or on school buses, children under two (2)
years old may wear face coverings but are not required to do so.
4. Face coverings need not be worn by employees or students who are outdoors and who are able to maintain social distancing of at least six (6) feet.
5. Notwithstanding the above, any individual who contends that he/she has a disability or condition which prohibits him/her from wearing a face covering inside school facilities or on school buses shall have the right to seek an exception to such requirement through the procedures outlined in Section J(1), (2), and (3) below.
F. Hygienic Supplies
1. Students, employees, and school visitors shall be provided adequate access to hygienic supplies, including soap, hand sanitizer with at least
60% alcohol content, disinfectant wipes or spray, paper towels, and tissues. The quantity of hygienic supplies in each school or work location must be appropriate to the needs of that facility, and the quantity of hygienic supplies in individual classrooms must be appropriate to the role and the number and age of students or adults in such classroom.
2. Students and employees are expected to bring their own face coverings with them to school and/or work each day. However, disposable face coverings shall be available at each school for students, employees, and guests who do not have their own coverings on a particular date.
G. Transportation
1. School buses used to transport students must not exceed the following maximum capacity requirements:
a. Phase One – 25%, including adults, of the maximum capacity of the bus as determined by the bus manufacturer;
b. Phase Two – 50%, including adults, of the maximum capacity of the bus as determined by the bus manufacturer; and
c. Phase Three – 75%, including adults, of the maximum capacity of the bus as determined by the bus manufacturer.
2. Passengers on a school bus must be spaced to the greatest extent possible as follows:
a. Phase One – Passengers must ride one (1) per seat except that members of the same household may sit in the same seat or adjacent seats. Every second seat on the bus must remain empty; and
b. Phases Two and Three – Passengers must be dispersed throughout the bus to maximize social distancing to the greatest extent possible.
H. Student Programming Determinations
1. Each student placement determination as to whether distance or in-person education program should be made after consultation with the parent or custodian.
2. Each student placement determination should take into consideration a student’s unique academic, social, emotional, familial, and medical needs, as identified by the student’s parent or custodian.
3. Documentation of efforts made to communicate with parents or custodians about student programming, together with the results of such communications, shall be maintained.
I. Essential Visitors to School Facilities
1. Essential visitors are individuals who must enter schools or early learning centers in order to conduct visits in according with Louisiana law or policy. Essential visitors include, but are not limited to, individuals who:
a. Conduct observations;
b. Observe teacher candidates as part of the teacher preparation quality rating system; or
c. Provide essential support or services including, but not limited to, early intervention services, special education services, or mental health consultations.
2. Essential visitors must comply with the minimum health and safety standards contained in this policy including, without limitation, hand washing, temperature checks, and the wearing of face coverings.
J. Medical or Disability Impact Exceptions
As provided in Section 401(E) and Section 403(I) of Bulletin 741, the Board recognizes that there may be medical or disability impact exceptions to one or more of these standards specific to a given student, employee, or other person, and such exceptions will be considered on an individual basis as set forth below.
1. In order for a student to be granted an exception based upon a medical or disability issue:
a. The parent or legal guardian of the student shall submit a written application, by letter, memorandum, or email, to the principal of the school in which the student is or will be enrolled.
b. The application shall identify the specific provision(s) of Chapter 4 to which the exception is applicable.
c. The application shall include documentation from a qualified medical professional or healthcare provider identifying the medical or disability issue that the applicant contends affords the need for the exception.
d. The application shall also include a reference to whether the exception is related to a service or accommodation afforded in an existing Section 504 plan, individualized education plan (IEP), or individualized health plan (IHP).
e. If the application is related to an existing Section 504 plan, IEP, or IHP, the principal shall convene a meeting of the School Building Level Committee (SBLC) to review the application and the existing Section 504 plan, IEP, or IHP to determine if an exception is needed or whether the plan can be modified to alleviate the need for the exception. The SBLC shall provide its recommendation to the principal, who shall forward that recommendation with the application to the Superintendent.
f. The Superintendent or his/her designee shall make a decision on the application within three (3) working days of his/her receipt of it.
g. The written decision of the Superintendent or designee shall be provided by letter, memorandum, or email to the applicant, and the decision of the Superintendent or designee shall be final.
h. All documentation related to the application shall be incorporated into the student’s school record and, if applicable, made a part of the student’s Section 504 plan, IEP, or IHP.
2. In order for an employee to be granted an exception based on a medical or disability issue:
a. The employee shall submit a written application, by letter, memorandum, or email, to his/her immediate supervisor.
b. The application shall identify the specific provision(s) of Chapter 4 to which the exception is applicable.
c. The application shall include documentation from a qualified medical professional or healthcare provider identifying the medical or disability issue that the applicant contends affords the need for the exception.
d. If the immediate supervisor of the employee is not the Superintendent, the immediate supervisor shall promptly forward to the Superintendent or the Superintendent’s designee the application for review and consideration, and the Superintendent or his/her designee shall make a decision within three (3) working days of his/her receipt of the application.
e. If the Superintendent is the immediate supervisor of the employee seeking an exception, then the Superintendent or his/her designee shall make a decision on the application within three (3) working days of his/her receipt of it.
f. The written decision of the Superintendent or designee shall be provided by letter, memorandum, or email to the applicant, and the decision of the Superintendent or designee shall be final.
3. In order for anyone other than a student or employee to be granted an exception based on a medical or disability issue:
a. The individual seeking the exception must meet with the school principal or worksite supervisor to discuss the reason for and basis of such exception and to determine whether there are any possible accommodations that can be made. In the event that a reasonable accommodation cannot be identified by the principal or worksite supervisor, then the individual seeking the exception can submit a written application to the Superintendent or his/her designee for additional consideration.
b. In the application to the Superintendent or designee, the applicant shall identify the specific provision(s) of Chapter 4 to which the exception is applicable and shall include documentation from a qualified medical professional or healthcare provider identifying the medical or disability issue that the applicant contends affords the need for the exception.
c. The Superintendent or his/her designee shall make a decision on the application within three (3) working days of his/her receipt of it.
d. The written decision of the Superintendent or designee shall be provided by letter, memorandum, or email to the applicant, and the decision of the Superintendent or designee shall be final.
K. Meals
Standards regarding group sizes (Section A) and physical standards for the use of facilities (Section B) must be followed for meals in the cafeteria and elsewhere.
Breakfast and lunch for each student shall be prepared by the cafeteria staff under the direction of the cafeteria manager. The cafeteria manager shall be responsible to see that meals are distributed to students in such a manner as to limit contact between the cafeteria staff and students.
New Policy: July 2020
Ref: Louisiana Revised Statute Annotated Section 17:81, 17:439.1, 17:3391; Louisiana Handbook for School Administrators, Bulletin 741, Louisiana Department of Education.
***************************************
Marissa Voros
Regarding agenda item 3
I do not feel it is safe to return to in person traditional schooling. I am concerned for the health and safety of myself as a classroom teacher and my coworkers who are going to be exposed to the virus on a constant basis. COVID-19 cases are continuing to rise in St John the Baptist Parish and as a member of the St. John Association of Educators, I think school should be delayed until the COVID-19 cases are no longer a concern for our well-being.
Erika Wright
Item # 3
I feel worried about our students and staff returning to any type of in-person teaching right now. I'm concerned about the health of our community. This situation continues to be life-threatening. Today, Louisiana again has the highest per capita rates of COVID-19 in America. Our schools have two new realms we have to contend with: virtual teaching and a global pandemic. Minimizing the pandemic in St. John must take precedence at this time. It’s just where we are in this fight. I truly believe we should provide virtual teaching (in whatever way we are able) and focus on doing that to the best of our abilities.
Alison Hull
Agenda Item #3
Comment: I am concerned that the school board does not feel safe enough to hold a meeting together, but they feel certain that staff and students will be safe when school opens next week. What are your concerns about meeting in person? We have those same concerns only on a much larger scale because children are also involved. What is the hesitation with starting virtual and delaying the in person start? We are not prepared for this. Please do the right thing for the staff and students of St. John Parish.
Christopher Newman
Is it me or does it seem like things are being rushed to get these kids back in school ,what is the hurry is it that hard to adjust the calendar start the school year later when all the equipment for the children,(ex computers for all children)equipment the teachers need and most of the concerns can be addressed before school starts.
Alvin Scioneaux, Sr.
Item#3
My suggestion is that SJBP school board establishes a website to inform the community of confirmed positive cases, quarantined cases tested, quarantined cases not tested, or other. If anyone gets sick during the school year, rumors will start and ciaos will begin. It is better to keep the community informed. No names need to be mentioned, but the school came maintain some order with factual information. The schools need to be as transparent as possible.
Erika Nieva
Last year my daughter was sixth grade and it was not good for us to understand how to use "Remind and Teams" Now we use it for 4 months until Christmas. Will you offer a class in Spanish to help us with these programs. Thank you
LaTunya Creecy
Is there going to be a special plan for students who were struggling BEFORE Covid-19? As far as extra help/ assistance to stay caught up or catch up with school lessons If so, which grades at which schools will help be coming from?
And will it be an actual teacher with proper credentials to teach?
Thank your time.
Cindy Graham
Why is SBLC handling exceptions to the mask mandate for students with disabilities under IDEA and 504? Shouldn’t that be handled by the IEP or IAP teams respectively? It is not feasible for 24 students to be 6 feet apart in a classroom. The size of the room has to matter. I noticed that there is a new calendar stating that 30 minutes will be added to each days schedule until December 2020 to account for the delayed start date. How does this effect 10 month employees who did not have a delayed start?
Nelann Taylor
Item 4:
The re-entry date of students should be pushed back if the district staff and faculty return date was pushed back. We are now attempting to complete a rush job of preparing teachers and students efficiently and it is a disservice to adequately prepare adults and children. Please address the concerns of the 80+ SJBPS employees from the recent Zoom meeting. A compiled survey came from over 50 respondents. We are concerned that decisions are being made WITHOUT US FOR US. Unacceptable. We practice to model equality and equity for our students and yet we do not demonstrate this for our teachers. More than half of the district employees (mainly teachers) are NOT comfortable with returning to their school sites and classrooms forcefully without ANSWERS!
Blaine Robertson, Association Representative
On behalf of the St. John Association of Educators, we have determined that it is not in the best interest of staff, students, or the community to begin school in-person until Louisiana experiences a two week period without a new COVID-19 case or at least until we see a significant drop in infection and fatality rates. We take this position for a multitude of reasons, several of which are presented below:
Not only are infection and death rates increasing across our state and the nation, but St. John the Baptist Parish has made national headlines boasting the highest death rate per capita for coronavirus in the country.
We have every reason to believe that when employees and students return to sites around the district in the coming weeks, the virus will continue to be transmitted from asymptomatic carriers and spread throughout our schools and community.
As school districts around the country return to school, we are witnessing an alarming spike in the number of infections among staff and students. This could potentially thwart any efforts to return to school considering the number of teachers and students returning who are unaware that they have contracted the virus and pose a threat to others.
Since March, St. John employees have already been exposed on multiple occasions to the virus in school buildings in this district by individuals that confirmed testing positive.
MOTION BY: DeFrancesch
SECOND BY: Jones
No objections.
Roll Call:
9 Yeas – Holden, Burl, Keller, DeFrancesch, Jones, Johnson, Schum, Mitchell, Sanders
2 Absent – Wallace, Triche
The motion carried.
ITEM 4. BOARD ITEMS OF INTEREST
ITEM 5. ADJOURNMENT
The agenda having been completed, and there being no further business, there was a
MOTION BY: Jones
SECOND BY: DeFrancesch
MOTION: Motion for adjournment.
There were no objections.
9 Yeas – Holden, Burl, Keller, DeFrancesch, Jones, Johnson, Schum, Mitchell, Sanders
2 Absent – Wallace, Triche
The motion carried.
The meeting adjourned at 8:05 p.m.
_____________________________________ _____________________________________
Dr. Lynett Hookfin, Superintendent/Secretary Patrick H. Sanders, President